Dos and Don’ts for Choosing the Right Cruise

Pinterest Hidden ImagePinterest Hidden ImagePinterest Hidden Image

Choosing the right cruise can make or break your vacation, especially if it’s your first time setting sail. A poor experience could put you off cruising altogether, and you’d miss out on a great vacation option for future trips.

Our first cruise was with Royal Caribbean over 20 years ago. I didn’t research nearly as much at the time as I do now. I chose it for the Southern Caribbean itinerary and the convenience of departing from San Juan, PR, which also allowed me to visit family. The fact that it was a well-known brand gave me confidence to book. Thankfully, we had a fantastic experience, which turned us into cruise lovers.

Our second cruise, however, didn’t go as well. It was another big brand, chosen for its convenience and low price, departing from our home port in LA. Unfortunately, we encountered poor customer service, subpar food, and missed our planned destinations. We haven’t sailed with that line since, though we’ll give it another try next year. Over time, we’ve learned many lessons and developed a more flexible approach to cruising.

Featured image of a person looking at cruise ships with the text 'Choosing the Right Cruise' in the center.Pin

With many cruises under our belt and more on the horizon, we’ve come to appreciate that it’s about finding the right balance between what you want and what you’re willing to spend. I also understand the frustration of spending hard-earned money on a cruise that doesn’t meet expectations. For many of us, that one vacation a year is precious—or sometimes, we have to wait even longer.

So, let’s explore some dos and don’ts for choosing the right cruise. Ultimately, it’s all about finding something that fits your budget, travel style, and itinerary wishes. We usually start by looking at the itineraries, already knowing our travel style. You can always chat with a reputable cruise travel agent who can steer you in the right direction and assist you in booking everything.

Know Your Travel Style

Do: Define Your Perfect Cruise Experience

Think about what you want from your cruise vacation. Is this a family getaway, or are you looking for some serious R&R? Is the itinerary a priority, or do you prefer more days at sea? Decide what kind of atmosphere, activities, and destinations appeal to you most, and choose a cruise line and itinerary that aligns with those preferences.

  • Family-Friendly Cruises: Choose cruises with a wide range of activities for kids and families, such as water parks, kid-friendly shows, and family cabins.
  • No Kids: Do you prefer an adults-only environment? If your budget allows, explore adult-only options like Virgin Voyages or more luxurious lines like Viking, known for their peaceful, child-free atmosphere.
  • Specific Port Destinations: If particular destinations are a must, start by narrowing down your choices based on the itinerary and then choose a suitable cruise line.
  • Luxury First-Class Cruising: Consider a “hotel within a ship” category on larger cruise lines, which offers exclusive amenities and services, like The Haven on NCL, The Retreat on Celebrity, or The Yacht Club on MSC. Alternatively, look into smaller luxury cruise ships that provide a boutique, first-class cruising experience tailored to those seeking a more personalized and upscale journey.
  • Relaxation: Look for cruises with plenty of sea days, spa services, adult-only areas, and quiet lounges. Consider booking a spa-class cabin for added comfort and relaxation perks.

Don’t: Assume All Cruises Are the Same

While cruising has key similarities, not all cruise lines or ships are created equal. Each cruise line offers a different atmosphere, activities, and experience. Even ships within the same cruise line can differ significantly in style and amenities.

  • Cruise Line Differences: Some cruise lines focus on luxury with fine dining and sophisticated entertainment, while others cater to families with kid-friendly activities and entertainment. Make sure the cruise line matches what you’re looking for.
  • Ship Variations Within the Same Line: Don’t assume all ships from the same cruise line offer the same experience. Newer ships might have updated amenities and more diverse options, while older ships may lack some modern features. Look into specific ship details to ensure they meet your expectations.
  • Research Thoroughly: Research the differences between cruise lines and ships. Read reviews, watch videos, and consider consulting with a travel agent to find the best match for your travel style.

Budget Beyond the Base Fare

Do: Add Up All Costs When Budgeting

While the base fare of a cruise usually covers accommodations, standard meals, entertainment, and basic drinks, there are many additional expenses to consider. Port fees, taxes, and gratuities often come as extra charges, so be sure they are included in your calculations.

Don’t forget other potential costs like transportation to the port, pre- or post-cruise hotel stays, specialty dining, shore excursions, alcoholic beverages, spa treatments, and onboard activities such as gambling. Knowing the total cost upfront will help you avoid surprises and budget more effectively.

Don’t: Choose a Cruise Solely Based on Price

Please don’t choose a cruise because it’s the cheapest or most convenient. Cheaper doesn’t always mean better. While we all love a good deal, a low-cost cruise doesn’t always offer the best value or experience. You may end up spending more on extras or dealing with lower quality. Instead, consider the overall value you’re getting for your money—sometimes, paying a bit more upfront can lead to a significantly better experience.

Do: Look for Inclusive Options

Some cruises offer all-inclusive cruise fares that include everything you may want in a cruise. Compare what’s included in each fare to find the best value for your budget and preferences. Virgin Voyages is one of those cruise lines that includes everything from soda, basic Wi-Fi, gratuities, fitness classes, and more in the cost of your cruise.

Do: Look for Promotions and Discounts

Cruise lines frequently offer promotions and discounts that can add significant value to your trip, such as onboard credits, free upgrades, drink packages, or free fares for kids. To stay informed about these deals, sign up for newsletters from cruise lines you’re interested in and consider working with a travel agent.

For example, Norwegian Cruise Line (NCL) often offers a “Free at Sea” promotion that includes free specialty dining and an unlimited drink package.

Choose the Right Cruise Line and Ship Size

Do: Research Cruise Lines

Each cruise line offers a unique experience. Some, like NCL, Royal Caribbean, Carnival, and Disney, are known for lively atmospheres and diverse activities—Disney, in particular, is celebrated for its family-friendly focus and themed entertainment. Others, like Celebrity Cruises and Holland America, provide a more refined, relaxed experience. Luxury lines such as Silversea or Seabourn offer all-inclusive service with smaller ships visiting exclusive ports.

  • Choose a cruise line that aligns with your desired atmosphere: Energetic, family-friendly, quiet, sophisticated, or ultra-luxurious.
  • Understand the typical demographics: Some cruise lines are geared towards families and younger travelers, while others appeal more to couples, solo travelers, or older adults. Knowing who each line attracts can help you pick a cruise that matches your style and what you’re looking.
  • Learn the differences between cruise lines and ships: Read reviews, watch virtual tours, and consult with a travel agent to find the best fit for your preferences.

Do: Get Expert Advice from a Travel Agent

Travel agents with cruise experience can help you navigate the various options, suggest cruise lines and ships that match your needs, and book everything when you’re ready. They may also have insider knowledge of deals and perks and can provide personalized advice, saving you time and possibly money. They can’t charge you more than what the cruise line is offering.

Don’t: Overlook Ship Size

Ship size affects your cruise experience. Larger ships have many activities, entertainment, and dining options but can feel busy. Smaller ships offer a more intimate atmosphere, personalized service, and access to unique ports but may have fewer onboard amenities.

Don’t: Assume All Ships from the Same Line Are the Same

Ships within the same cruise line can vary significantly. Different ship classes offer unique experiences; even ships within the same class can differ in themes, amenities, and sometimes service. For example, our cruises on Celebrity’s Solstice Class ships differed from those on the newer, more modern Celebrity Edge Class ships, which feature larger spaces and unique amenities like the Magic Carpet.

Newer ships often have more up-to-date features, while older ships might provide a similar experience at a lower cost.

Pick Your Perfect Itinerary

Do: Decide on the Length of Your Cruise

Think about how much time you have and what feels suitable for you. Shorter cruises (3-5 days) are ideal for first-timers or those with limited time, while longer cruises (7 days or more) give you the opportunity to visit places that you can’t reach on a shorter cruise.

Do: Choose an Itinerary That Matches Your Interests

Cruising offers the unique opportunity to visit multiple destinations in a short amount of time. While we often choose cruises for their itineraries, sometimes the ship itself can be the main attraction. You can opt for a port-intensive cruise with frequent stops or select one with more sea days to relax and enjoy the ship’s amenities. If there are port stops, you also have the option to stay on board and make the most of the quieter ship while others explore ashore.

  • Consider Your Destination: Choose an itinerary that takes you to destinations you’re excited to visit, whether the Caribbean, Mediterranean, Alaska, Mexico, or Asia.
  • Balance Sea and Port Days: Find a balance that suits your style—more sea days for relaxation or more port stops for exploration.
  • Look for Unique Itineraries: Consider cruises with overnight stays, unique routes, or visits to lesser-known ports. We love cruising to Bermuda because it has two overnight stays, and recently, we booked a cruise to the Southern Caribbean that includes an overnight in Aruba, allowing us more time to explore.

Don’t: Forget the Seasons

The seasons can make a big difference when cruising. Because of hurricane season, you won’t find as many ships heading to the Caribbean in the summer. Alaska cruises run from late April to early October, but summer is often the best time to sail for nicer weather.

Do: Research Ports

Look into the ports of call on your potential cruise itineraries. Some ports offer a wide range of activities right at the dock, while others may require more travel to explore. If there are specific destinations or activities you’re excited about, make sure they’re included in the itinerary. Knowing what each port offers will help you pick a cruise that matches your interests.

  • Consider Transportation Needs: Some ports are easy to navigate on foot, while others may require transportation or an excursion to be booked. Understanding this can help you choose a cruise itinerary that aligns with your comfort and activity preferences.
  • Find Activities That Interest You: Choose a cruise with ports that offer the experiences you’re looking for, like diving in the Caribbean, wine tours in the Mediterranean, or glacier walks in Alaska.

Consider Onboard Amenities and Atmosphere

Lounge seating area in the thermal spa on the NCL Encore cruise ship.

Do: Prioritize the Amenities That Matter Most to You

Think about what amenities will make your cruise enjoyable. If you love staying active, choose a ship with fitness centers, pools, sports courts, or rock-climbing walls. If you prefer relaxation, look for ships with adult-only areas, spa services, and quiet lounges. Make sure the ship offers the features that align with your interests.

Don’t: Assume All Ships Have the Same Amenities

Not all ships offer the same facilities. Some may have multiple pools, a wide range of dining options, or unique features like ice skating rinks or go-kart tracks. Others might have more limited choices. Check the specific ship’s amenities before booking to ensure it meets your expectations.

Don’t: Ignore How Season and Demographics Affect Atmosphere

The ship’s atmosphere can change depending on the season and who’s onboard. Cruises during school holidays might be filled with families, while off-season cruises may have more retirees or adults. Research your cruise line and sailing dates to ensure they align with your desired experience.

Choose the Right Cabin Category

Do: Know That There Are Different Cabin Types

Cruise ships offer a range of cabin types, from interior rooms with no windows to ocean-view cabins, balcony staterooms, and luxurious suites. Usually, the lowest price you see advertised is for an interior room. Decide which type fits your budget and needs. If you are claustrophobic, you may want to skip the interior room. If you enjoy natural light and fresh air, splurge on the balcony cabin.

Don’t: Ignore the Cabin Location

Cabin location matters. Some cabins are close to elevators, staircases, or entertainment venues and can be noisy, while others might be more private and quieter. Think about factors like mid-ship stability if you’re prone to seasickness or a location near amenities for convenience. Our all-around recommendation is to pick a cabin as close to mid-ship as possible that has cabins located above, below, and next to it.

Don’t: Forget About Upgrades and Perks

Higher-category cabins often come with additional perks, such as priority boarding, exclusive dining, or access to special areas. Weigh the benefits against the cost to decide if these extras are worth it for you.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Don’t: Ignore the Fine Print

I know it’s tempting to skip the fine print when booking travel—I’ve done it myself! But it’s important to take the time to read and understand the cruise line’s terms and conditions before committing. Everything is usually spelled out, from the cancellation policy to the fact that itineraries can change anytime. Understanding these details upfront can help you avoid surprises later on and weigh that decision on what cruise is right for you.

Don’t: Disregard the Cancellation Policy

Make sure you’re familiar with the cruise line’s cancellation policy and final payment deadlines. Not understanding these terms could lead to unexpected penalties or even losing a significant portion of your payment if you need to cancel. Cancellation policy can vary slightly between cruise lines and may sway your decision on choosing the right cruise.

How to Choose the Right Cruise

Now that you’ve seen the dos and don’ts of selecting a cruise let’s put it all together with a step-by-step approach. These steps will guide you through making the best choices for your cruise experience, from choosing your travel style to booking the perfect cabin. Follow these tips to ensure your next cruise is everything you hope for and mo

  1. Identify Your Travel Style: Take some time to think about what kind of experience you want from your cruise.
  2. Decide on the Length of Your Cruise: Consider how much time you have and how long you’d like to be at sea. First-time cruisers might prefer a shorter trip, while seasoned travelers may enjoy longer itineraries with more destinations.
  3. Set a Realistic Budget: The cruise fare does cover the basics, which is nice, but it does not cover additional expenses you need to factor into your budget.
  4. Research Cruise Lines and Ships: Look into different cruise lines and ships to find those that best match your preferences, onboard amenities, ship size, and typical crowd.
  5. Pick Your Itinerary: Choose an itinerary with destinations you’re excited to visit within the length of cruise. Balance sea days with port days and consider the seasonal weather at each location.
  6. Consider the Onboard Atmosphere: Decide on the onboard atmosphere that suits you—lively, relaxed, or something in between. Read reviews and ship descriptions to find your match.
  7. Choose the Right Cabin: Select a cabin that fits your needs and budget, whether it’s an affordable interior, an ocean view, or a suite with added perks.
  8. Read the Fine Print: Review the cruise line’s policies, including cancellation terms.
  9. Book Your Cruise: Once you’ve decided, book your cruise directly through the cruise line, a cruise agent, or an online travel agency. Consider travel insurance to safeguard your plans.

Kathy Ava

Meet Kathy Ava, a food, travel, and cruise writer based in Los Angeles/Pasadena, and the owner and main writer of Tasty Itinerary. With over 20 years of experience planning trips and logistics at her full-time job and for herself, she's become a pro at crafting unforgettable tasty itineraries. She's always on the hunt for delicious, fun travel destinations and cruise itineraries. She firmly believes that life is short and we must make the most of it, so always say yes to dessert.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *